Website in Spanish       Website in Portuguese coming soon
Member Area

Nonproliferation for Global Security Foundation - NPSGlobal

Oct 23rd
PDF Print E-mail

North Korean Future in Doubt after Execution of Second in Command

Center for Strategic & International Studies
Ralph A. Cossa ( This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it ) is president of Pacific Forum CSIS.

19 Dec 2013| Link to the original article

Those hoping for regime change in North Korea may have just gotten their wish . . . it’s just not the type of change they had been hoping for.

The purge and subsequent quick execution of North Korea’s number two leader, Jang Song-thaek, proves once again the dangers associated with being next in line in an authoritarian society. Even being the number one guy’s uncle (by marriage, not by birth) cannot save you.

What all this means for the stability of the regime and for its future policy is anyone’s guess, and it’s important to remember that when it comes to North Korea, we’re all guessing. The frustrating part about analyzing North Korean actions is that every event has at least two equally plausible but diametrically opposed explanations.

The experts seem divided between those who think that Jang’s removal from power reflects Kim Jong-un’s total control – he is now secure enough to remove the mentor his father chose for him – and those who believe that it reflects just how unstable and insecure the 20-something leader really is.

I’m inclined toward the latter but we need to see who else is purged or rehabilitated; over 40 percent of the senior leadership has been removed or retired in the not quite two years since Kim Jong-un has come to power, including some potential Jang rivals who might now make a comeback. Clearly the last shoe has yet to fall.text that will appear at the begining

One thing is sure: the previously purged Jang won’t be making a comeback. Putting him to death – common for lower-ranking individuals but rare for senior leaders, especially members of the ruling family – could show how insecure Kim is about his ability to truly neutralize his once-powerful uncle. Remember the old maxim about “killing the chicken to scare the monkeys”? Kim went straight for the monkey. Can you imagine how scared the chickens must now be?

While much remains to be sorted out, what seems clear (at least to me) is that “Chinese-style reform” has become increasingly unlikely for North Korea. Jang had long been seen as its number one advocate; the Chinese treated Jang like a visiting head of state when he visited Beijing in 2012. While there, he reportedly assured the Chinese leadership that, in return for Chinese support for the new boy leader, Kim Jong-un would, with Jang’s encouragement and supervision, eventually take the North down the Chinese path.

In all likelihood, this line of thinking has been at least temporarily discredited. Even if his purge was all about power and personalities rather than policy, it would be very dangerous for others to be seen as supporting Jang’s policy prescriptions at this time. If reports that China received no advance warning of this event and that some Jang supporters are seeking asylum in China are true, this bodes ill not only for the China model, but perhaps for the overall Sino-North Korean relationship as well. The fact that Jang’s long list of sins included selling North Korean assets too cheaply to China must be additional salt in China's wound.

Chinese colleagues sometimes tell me, only half jokingly, that they want to bring their children to North Korea to let them see what China was like in the old days, before Deng Xiaoping led the country down the path of reform. Many in China seemed to believe (or at least hoped) that Jang Song-thaek would turn out to be the North’s Deng Xiaoping. Recall it was the twice-purged Deng who pulled off his own internal coup in 1976, bringing about the regime change in China that ousted the so-called “Gang of Four,” led by Mao’s widow Jiang Qing.

While others will watch closely for changes in North Korean policy as a result of Jang’s purge and execution, it is the change we are not likely to see that could be most significant. The chances of Deng-styled reform in North Korea may have just died along with Jang. Imagine China’s fate if the Gang of Four had prevailed. This may have been what just happened in Pyongyang.


  • Pause
  • Previous
  • Next
Terror Unleashed: the coming terrorism

Noticias, Irma Argüello, August 17, 2017.

Military defeat of ISIS in Middle East was something like “Kick the anthill” generating a Diaspora of terrorists around the world.

World is moved by a new terrorist attack, this time in Barcelona. This adds up to the continuity of acts that begun in January 2015 in Paris with the assault of Charlie Hebdo and continued in various European cities.  All those acts left a balance of more than 480 dead and 1100 injured since 2015 to now.

Read more
Global Security
U.N. report says Iran reduces sensitive uranium stockpiles by 75 percent

NPSGlobal Foundation, 17 Apr 2014.

A United Nations report Thursday said that Iran has reduced its stockpiles of sensitive uranium by 75% as part of a deal with six world powers seeking assurances of the peaceful nature of the country’s nuclear program, Reuters news agency reported.

The International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), said Iran had diluted half of its reserves of uranium with 20% enrichment.

Under the terms of the agreement, the other half of the country’s sensitive uranium reserves were to be converted to oxide. Reuters said that the U.N. agency reported that this process was halfway completed.

Nuclear & Radiological Weapons
U.S. Prosecutors Accuse Man of Holding Lethal Uranium Cache U.S. Prosecutors Accuse Man of Holding Lethal Uranium Cache

Global Security Newswire, 16 Apr 2014.

A terminated U.S. Army facility worker faces charges for holding what was thought to be a deadly form of uranium, the Newark Star-Ledger reports.

Police detained 44-year-old Joseph Gibeau on Saturday after allegedly finding radioactive substances inside several lead-shielded containers at his home while responding to a domestic call, the newspaper reported on Tuesday. Two containers reportedly held a substance tentatively identified by authorities as uranium sulfate, a potentially lethal chemical.

Chem & Bio Weapons
OPCW says Syria has no margin for delays in destruction of chemical weapons OPCW says Syria has no margin for delays in destruction of chemical weapons

NPSGlobal Foundation, 14 Abr 2014.

The leader of the global monitoring group that is helping oversee the eradication of Syria’s chemical weapons arsenal said Monday President Bashar al-Assad’s government has no more margin for delays if it is to meet the June deadline for destruction of its arsenal.

Ahmet Üzümcü, director general of the Organization for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons (OPCW) said the removal of the chemicals had fallen behind a revised schedule that called for the delivery process to be completed by April 27.

Delivery Systems
North Korea Said to Move Missile Launcher to Coast North Korea Said to Move Missile Launcher to Coast

Global Security Newswire, 17 Apr 2014.

North Korea reportedly has deployed a mobile rocket launcher to its east coast in a possible sign that a threatened missile test is imminent.

A transporter-erector-launcher was detected moving toward the North's coast, an anonymous senior South Korean government official told the JoongAng Ilbo newspaper for a Tuesday report.

The mobile launcher was earlier fielded at the North's "central front," the official said. "North Korea made similar moves before the launch of its short-range FROG rockets and KN-09 ballistic missiles in late February and early March."

Conventional Arms
U.N. official urges action to assure that killer robots remain under human control U.N. official urges action to assure that killer robots remain under human control

NPSGlobal Foundation, 13 May 2014.

A high-level U.N. official today opened a four-day conference on lethal autonomous weapons encouraging delegates to take bold action to assure that the ultimate decision to take life remain under human control.

Non-state Actors
Study sees possible manufacture of guidance systems by a Chinese proliferator as a threat to peace

NPSGlobal Foundation, 21 may 2014.

A study by security experts of a British university said that a Chinese businessman, who has been accused of supplying prohibited technology to Iran, may have begun manufacturing a key component of guidance systems for ballistic missiles, seriously threatening international peace and security.

Nuclear Energy
Building at Fukushima accidentally flood with 200 tons of radioactive water Building at Fukushima accidentally flood with 200 tons of radioactive water

NPSGlobal Foundation, 18 Apr 2014

The operator of the Fukushima nuclear power plant accidentally directed 200 tons of highly radioactive water to a building within the plant site that was not supposed to receive the contaminated water, the Japan Daily Press reported Thursday.

Plant operator Tokyo Electric Power Co. (TEPCO) told the Japan Daily Press that Japan’s Nuclear Regulatory Authority (NRA) ordered the company to monitor for leakage even though TEPCO assured that the facility was watertight.

TEPCO reported that the highly contaminated water, which is used for cooling the disabled reactors, had been mistakenly routed to a group of buildings that house the central waste processing facilities for the plant.

Sensitive Materials
Japanese columnist says Washington may soon force Japan to accept traditional safeguards Japanese columnist says Washington may soon force Japan to accept traditional safeguards

NPSGlobal Foundation, Apr 14, 2014.

A Japanese columnist today said Washington may soon force Prime Minister Shinzo Abe’s government to accept traditional safeguards on its nuclear materials unless it backs down from its confrontational stance with neighboring countries.

Norihiro Kato, a contributing opinion writer for the New York Times and literary professor at Waseda University, said in an Op-Ed piece in the newspaper that if Abe “continues on his confrontational agenda, his government may lose Washington’s support.”

Strategic Trade
Zimbabwe Minister Denies Report of Uranium Contract with Iran Zimbabwe Minister Denies Report of Uranium Contract with Iran

By Godfrey Marawanyika & Kevin Crowley, Bloomberg, 10 Aug 2013.

Zimbabwe hasn’t signed an agreement allowing uranium exports to Iran, Deputy Mining Minister Gift Chimanikire said, after a media report the country entered into a deal to export the material used to build nuclear weapons.

Prevention & Response
Los Alamos given deadline to secure nuclear-waste barrels linked to radiation leak Los Alamos given deadline to secure nuclear-waste barrels linked to radiation leak

NPSGlobal Foundation, 20 May 2014.

The state of New Mexico in the southwestern region of the United States has given the Los Alamos National Laboratory a deadline for securing 57 nuclear-waste barrels that were linked to a radiation leak in February, according to news reports.

New Mexico Environment Secretary Ryan Flynn said the nuclear-waste drums may pose an “imminent” and “substantial” danger to health or the environment, NBC News reported. He said the laboratory had until Wednesday to propose how to secure the barrels to prevent further leaks.


All materials available

Banner International Seminar 2014

Education for Peace

Regional Postgraduate Course in International Security, Disarmament and Non-proliferation

Registration Open

An Excellent Educational Option for 2017

banner posgrado 2



"Our vision: A World Free of Weapons of Mass Destruction"